• Home
  • Ukraine War
  • Economy
  • State of Affair
  • Opinion
  • Video

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

What's Hot

Upbeat Economic Outlook issued for China

March 29, 2023

US Becoming a ‘Banana Republic’ – Trump

March 28, 2023

China and Russia Top List of States With Largest Trade Surplus

March 28, 2023
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending
  • Upbeat Economic Outlook issued for China
  • US Becoming a ‘Banana Republic’ – Trump
  • China and Russia Top List of States With Largest Trade Surplus
  • China Could be ‘Safe Haven’ Amid Banking Turmoil – Citi
  • The First Australian Soldier has Been Charged Over Afghanistan War Crimes, But those Ultimately Responsible Remain in Command
  • US Democracy ‘a Facade’ – Russian Security Chief
  • How Joe Biden and the CIA Orchestrated the 2014 “Revolution” to Instigate War Between NATO and Russia in Ukraine
  • Washington Seeks Banking Crisis Advice from Warren Buffet – Bloomberg
Wednesday, March 29
Facebook Twitter Instagram
RT NewsRT News
  • Home
  • Ukraine War
  • Economy
  • State of Affair
  • Opinion
  • Video
RT NewsRT News
Home » Why are People Afraid of ‘15-minute Cities’?
Lifestyle

Why are People Afraid of ‘15-minute Cities’?

adminBy adminMarch 1, 2023No Comments6 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Pinterest Email

Why are People Afraid of ‘15-minute Cities’?

By Robert Bridge | RT News

In an effort to make towns more user- and eco-friendly, urban planners have unveiled the ’15-minute city,’ which hopes to keep residents close to home to battle climate change. But will this plan open the door to greater restrictions?

More than 2,000 protesters went out into the streets of Oxford, England earlier this month to express their hostility to the controversial concept of the 15-minute city, which has already been quietly unveiled in a number of major cities, including Barcelona, Melbourne, Paris and Milan.

Centered on the work of the French-Colombian urbanist Carlos Moreno, 15-minute cities are designed so that human necessities and services, like shopping, work, education, and healthcare are accessible with a short bike ride or walk from one’s front door. Such a city is divided into neighborhoods or zones, and local residents have little to no need to ever travel outside their immediate surroundings. When necessary, such trips can be taken via public transport or ring roads, keeping private cars’ harmful emissions into the city air at a minimum.

At first glance, it seems hard to argue with this proposal. After all, most people at one time or another have found themselves cursing at automobiles, maybe even chasing after them with a clenched fist (as an Australian friend of mine was prone to do when the cars didn’t stop for him in the crosswalks), wishing that the contraptions would just disappear.

In fact, something like that happened recently in the center of Moscow when the local government converted several lengthy streets around Red Square to pedestrian traffic only. The results have been spectacular. Along spacious roads once reserved for the fire-breathing machines, young people ride electric scooters, kids run without fear of becoming roadkill, and diners enjoy casual meals on patios minus vehicular noise and pollution. Meanwhile, the businesses do not seem negatively affected by the change. In fact, they seem to be flourishing like never before. So where exactly is the problem?

It seems that much of the skepticism and even paranoia about 15-minute cities stems from recent history, particularly humanity’s experience with the Covid pandemic and the restrictive methods that some world leaders chose for dealing with it. What started off as “15 days of lockdowns to flatten the curve” of the disease with a survival rate above 95%, turned into what many feel was a marathon in prison living. These skeptics now see 15-minute cities as a continuation of the dreaded ‘Great Reset’, a part of the unsettling formula of ‘You’ll own nothing and you’ll be happy.’ They view the idea of renouncing at-will car travel as something akin to “eating bugs”, which is already being promoted as a way to mitigate climate change. And they are asking: can people who promote such ideas be trusted with regulating day-to-day city life?

To further complicate matters, the very idea that climate change is a problem that must be fought at all costs is an issue that seems to be as controversial as the great debate over abortion or gun control in the US. Some people, many of them on the political right, see this environmentalism as nothing more than an excuse for exerting more government control over people. Besides, the 15-minute city’s ability to help the environment has itself been called into question.

During the Oxford protest, one of the speakers, a 12-year-old girl named Jasmine, provided an imaginary scenario: “Let’s say my friend lives in Zone 3 and I’m in Zone 1. If, for example, I went to my friend’s house in Zone 3. My parents normally come and pick me up in their car, it only takes 10 minutes. So does that mean that they’d have to go around the ring road and back into town again? If my mom or dad had to drive around the ring road, it would take 30 minutes, causing much more pollution and leaving a much bigger carbon footprint.” 

Moreover, is it realistic to think that every material good and service will always be readily accessible by a 15-minute bicycle ride or casual stroll? After all, what government bureaucrats promise and what they ultimately provide seldom align. And let’s not forget that business failures happen on a regular basis and often with little notice. Will residents of Zone 1, for example, be forced to pay fines in the event they must travel to Zone 5 for essential products, like food, medicine and even water in the event of unexpected shortfalls?

Even if a self-contained neighborhood is ultimately able to maintain stable access to all the wants and needs of its residents, opponents of the idea have gone so far as to compare it to a gulag. They feel the 15-minute city would deprive them of the freedom of choice to leave their neighborhoods and venture to other businesses, schools, and health services without having to fork over money, time and nerves for the privilege.

“The idea that neighborhoods should be walkable is lovely,” Dr. Jordan Peterson commented over Twitter. “The idea that idiot tyrannical bureaucrats can decide by fiat where you’re ‘allowed’ to drive is perhaps the worst imaginable perversion of that idea – and, make no mistake, it’s part of a well-documented plan.” 

Additionally, there are other socio-economic questions regarding equal opportunity, privilege, and even race. Nobody has been able to predict the consequences of imposing travel restrictions on more marginalized consumers who lack quality services in their poorer neighborhoods, and must now pay more to access them at a much greater distance. 

Oxford’s 15-minute-city plans themselves do not actually include traffic restrictions or fines, instead focusing on making the scheme workable by ensuring that residents have access to everything they need. This includes boosting local retail, improving delivery services and other, equally benevolent measures with no encroachment on personal freedoms. Given this, the detractors of the 15-minute city have been dubbed conspiracy theorists. 

However, Oxfordshire City Council also has a separate plan, a set of traffic-reducing measures that will go into trial mode next year. Under this plan, residents will not be allowed to drive on some city streets for most of the day unless they have a 100-day permit. They are encouraged to instead use the ring road or public transport. Traffic cameras will monitor compliance and fines will be imposed for violations.

The aforementioned ‘conspiracy theorists’ in Oxford have been accused of conflating the two plans to make the idea of the 15-minute city seem more ominous than it is. But their concerns are justified by the power creep they’ve seen during and after the Covid-related lockdowns – where we now know that digital tracking measures have been used for more than just reducing the spread of the virus.

Back in 1986, former US president Ronald Reagan famously told a group of journalists, “The nine most terrifying words in the English language are: I’m from the government, and I’m here to help.” Those protesting the idea of 15-minute cities believe they need to get a foot in the door before the power creep actually does start encroaching on personal freedoms – which they now feel is the inevitable outcome.

Original Source: https://www.rt.com/news/572123-15minute-cities-control-protests/

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp Email
admin
  • Website

Related Posts

New Zealand Parliament Bans TikTok

March 18, 2023

US Markets are Now in ‘Death Zone’ – Morgan Stanley

February 28, 2023

Wall Street Suffers Worst Day of 2023

February 23, 2023

A ‘World Government’ May End Humanity – Musk

February 17, 2023

Musk Wants New Twitter CEO by the End of the Year

February 16, 2023

Adidas Braced for Substantial Losses Following Kanye Split

February 14, 2023
Add A Comment

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Don't Miss

Upbeat Economic Outlook issued for China

By adminMarch 29, 2023

Upbeat Economic Outlook issued for China By RT News S&P Global Ratings forecasts 5.5% GDP…

US Becoming a ‘Banana Republic’ – Trump

March 28, 2023

China and Russia Top List of States With Largest Trade Surplus

March 28, 2023

China Could be ‘Safe Haven’ Amid Banking Turmoil – Citi

March 28, 2023
Our Picks

Upbeat Economic Outlook issued for China

March 29, 2023

US Becoming a ‘Banana Republic’ – Trump

March 28, 2023

China and Russia Top List of States With Largest Trade Surplus

March 28, 2023

China Could be ‘Safe Haven’ Amid Banking Turmoil – Citi

March 28, 2023

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from SmartMag about art & design.

About Us
About Us

Your source for the lifestyle news. This demo is crafted specifically to exhibit the use of the theme as a lifestyle site. Visit our main page for more demos.

We're accepting new partnerships right now.

Email Us: info@example.com
Contact: +1-320-0123-451

Our Picks

Nuclear Family: How Ukraine Helped North Korea Develop the World’s Deadliest Weapons

July 2, 2022

Russia Announces $14.5bn Domestic Airline Boost

June 30, 2022

Ukrainian Mayor Blames Shopping Mall Management For Deaths

June 30, 2022

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

Facebook Instagram
  • Home
  • Ukraine War
  • Economy
  • State of Affair
  • Opinion
  • Video
© 2023 Russia-Ukraine.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.